I just had one of the most disturbing conversations.
Two women told me (in disgust) that the singer, Gwen Stefani, has this entourage of silent Japanese women following her around like fashion accessories.
I couldn't believe it.
I just went online to verify it. Here is what I've found...
www.brianbehrend.com/archive...is_a.php
www.stirtv.com/MessageBoard/Thread.aspx
www.kissui.net/mt/archives/000964.html
Harajuku
The release of her solo album has also brought attention to Stefani's entourage of four harajuku girls. Named Love, Angel, Music, and Baby respectively by Stefani, the 'harajuku' girls are named for the area around the Harajuku Station of Tokyo, Japan, known as a popular shopping destination and fashion center for teenagers. Following their namesake area, Stefani's harajuku girls are usually flamboyantly dressed (sometimes in a somewhat "Gothic Lolita" style), and they have been featured in her music videos, press coverage, on the album cover for Love. Angel. Music. Baby., and have a song dedicated to them on the album.
However, Stefani's adoption of this component of Japanese culture has drawn criticism from some quarters; for example, Mihi Ahn at Salon.com writes: 'Stefani has taken the idea of Japanese street fashion and turned these women into modern-day geisha, contractually obligated to speak only Japanese in public, even though it's rumored they're just plain old Americans and their English is just fine... she's swallowed a subversive youth culture in Japan and barfed up another image of submissive giggling Asian women.' [1]
from wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gwen_Stefani
Amazing!
In the course of this conversation with the two women, a white male said he will send her a letter saying "Go Girl!" for having the guts to do this. He said that if these girls consent to being her slaves, then that's fine.
My opinion: Disgusted.
I just don't know what to think. I am so disturbed by this right now that I feel like kicking someones face in.
Its supposed to be a tribute to Japanese street fashion, but she's turned it into some sort of fucked up display of cultural insensitivity.
Perhaps she's baiting us. More attention, more record sales.
Perhaps the Asian American youth actually like this.
Any of these thought disturb me.
Two women told me (in disgust) that the singer, Gwen Stefani, has this entourage of silent Japanese women following her around like fashion accessories.
I couldn't believe it.
I just went online to verify it. Here is what I've found...
www.brianbehrend.com/archive...is_a.php
www.stirtv.com/MessageBoard/Thread.aspx
www.kissui.net/mt/archives/000964.html
Harajuku
The release of her solo album has also brought attention to Stefani's entourage of four harajuku girls. Named Love, Angel, Music, and Baby respectively by Stefani, the 'harajuku' girls are named for the area around the Harajuku Station of Tokyo, Japan, known as a popular shopping destination and fashion center for teenagers. Following their namesake area, Stefani's harajuku girls are usually flamboyantly dressed (sometimes in a somewhat "Gothic Lolita" style), and they have been featured in her music videos, press coverage, on the album cover for Love. Angel. Music. Baby., and have a song dedicated to them on the album.
However, Stefani's adoption of this component of Japanese culture has drawn criticism from some quarters; for example, Mihi Ahn at Salon.com writes: 'Stefani has taken the idea of Japanese street fashion and turned these women into modern-day geisha, contractually obligated to speak only Japanese in public, even though it's rumored they're just plain old Americans and their English is just fine... she's swallowed a subversive youth culture in Japan and barfed up another image of submissive giggling Asian women.' [1]
from wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gwen_Stefani
Amazing!
In the course of this conversation with the two women, a white male said he will send her a letter saying "Go Girl!" for having the guts to do this. He said that if these girls consent to being her slaves, then that's fine.
My opinion: Disgusted.
I just don't know what to think. I am so disturbed by this right now that I feel like kicking someones face in.
Its supposed to be a tribute to Japanese street fashion, but she's turned it into some sort of fucked up display of cultural insensitivity.
Perhaps she's baiting us. More attention, more record sales.
Perhaps the Asian American youth actually like this.
Any of these thought disturb me.
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Sun, June 5, 2005 - 7:35 AMI don't see what the big deal is, personally.
All kind of entertainment artists employ hype men, so to speak. No one complained about Snoop and Bishop Magic Don Juan, or Kid Rock and Joe C, or Arrested Development and Baba Oje, or Prince and Diamond & Pearl.
Why should Gwen Stefani by singled out? Besides her, I didn't see anyone BUT Asians in the 'Hollaback Girl' video. If anything, I give her props for hiring so many Asians, in an industrial climate that generally excludes them, AND for cleverly promoting her ASIAN friend's clothing line, Bananas(for those who wonder what bananas had to do with anything). -
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Sun, June 5, 2005 - 3:41 PMLet me guess, Theodorus... you are not Asian.
The fact is, people have complained about ALL of the guys you mention and still do (although I will confess, I don't know what you are talking about with regards to Arrested Development and Baba Oje).
It's an issue of portrayal. If Kid Rock (who is a white boy who has appropriated rap, for those who might not know) had an entourage of black women following him around at all public events, silent, dressed all hootchie and he RENAMED them, oh, lets say, Peaches, Honey, Sweetness and Cootchie... you think he'd be in business?
Remember Vanilla Ice? His failed career stands as an example. No respect, no game.
Asiaphilia might seem cute and harmless, but there is a side to it that is demeaning. I am particularly worried about Asian and Asian American youth seeing themselves portrayed in this manner.
But what do you care?
You gonna give D.W. Griffith props for hiring so many blacks to play demeaning roles in "Birth of a Nation"?
-
-
Unsu...
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Mon, June 6, 2005 - 10:41 AMGwen Stefani sucks!
No seriously, I am too offended by her stereotype of Japanese clubbers/teenagers, especially since Harijuku used to be hang out of mine on Sunday afternoons in the 80s when I lived in Tokyo. While 20 years is a long time, Harijuku is still the same place and same style. Even the pronucation of Harijuku is silly (Eve makes me laugh).
Theodorus was referring to Baba Oje (who I saw recently on that cheesy "Hit Me Baby One More Time" show) of Arrested Development. I think he has it wrong putting him in this context though. Baba Oje, while perhaps quiet or silent on stage was very much the spiritual advisor to Speech the leader of Arrested Development. And don't get me STARTED on Kid Rock it's not the subject though I have to point out that he used Hip Hop as a resume starter.......and people allowed him to.
Good thread.
One Love,
Darren/Zulu -
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Tue, June 7, 2005 - 7:53 AM>> Baba Oje, while perhaps quiet or silent on stage was very much the spiritual advisor to Speech the leader of Arrested Development.
<<
A spiritual advisor is a far cry from a slave/pet/fashion accessory,
isn't it?
Remember Public Enemy's S1W's?
The silent military/martial arts drill team
that used to show up at all the shows?
Maybe THAT's it!
Maybe these "Harijuku girls" are actually
Gwen's secret NINJA BODYGUARDS!
Ooooooh.
Now I'm scared...
-
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Mon, June 6, 2005 - 1:00 PMNo, Sensei, I'm not Asian. I'm Black, Tsalagi, and Scottish. Should I limit my cultural exposure to only those things produced by African Americans, Native Americans, and Scotts? Should I surrender my license in Iga Ryu Ninpo Taijutsu, from the Bujunkan Dojo of Masaaki Hatsumi, simply because I am not Japanese?
Baba Oje is the older gentleman who appeared onstage everywhere with Arrested Development. He never did anything more than stand up on stage with them, even the other night when AD reunited onstage for that show 'Hit Me Baby, One More Time' on NBC, I never heard anyone complain that they were exploiting senior citizens. In fact, they were applauded for giving a brother a job.
Kid Rock did not appropriate rap. He grew up with (and dated), Black people, and was exposed to Hip-Hop as well as Rock & Roll (two forms of Black Music) most of his life. In the earlier part of his career he employed most of his neighborhood friends, including the strippers and his pornstar girlfriend, Midori (singer Jody Watley's twin sister). This was long before he even met the diminutive Joe C. Apparently yes, he would still be in business, since that's part of how he got so big in the first place.
Yes, I do remember MULTI-PLATINUM recording artist Vanilla Ice (hate on him all you want, but somebody bought the albums). I also remember Snow, Tarie B, Everlast, 3rd Bass (went to high school with MC Serch), House of Pain, Young Black Teenagers, Blood of Abraham, Bubba Sparxxx, Limp Bizkit, The Beastie Boys, and Teena Marie. Should I discount their contributions to my musical world, because they aren't Black?
Any who knows the history of Hip Hop knows that if Debbie Harry had not gone to hang out uptown with Fab 5 Freddy, one fateful night, and been so inspired by what she saw, Blondie would never have recorded 'Rapture'. It was a Caucasian punk rock band that brought an underground culture like Hip-Hop to the attention of the mainstream media.
My point with this, is that hip hop was strong enough to stand, and thrive, under commercial media exposure, and eventually grew bigger than it's initial proponent. It's possible that Harajuku can grow beyond Gwen Stefani, if it is stong enough. After all, these women aren't bound slaves, stored in an overcrowded cargo bin. They are highly paid, contracted, performance artists, hitching their wagons to a rising star, and hoping to get exposure on a world stage that they can easily parley to their own advantage. With the recent popularity of anime, more Japanese artists, like Hi Hi Puffy Ami Yumi, and the 5,6,7,8's are starting to get some light. It's a far more level socio-economic climate than when old D.W. was making movies.
Maybe if someone like Gwen had come along for Asians 20 years ago, an immense talent like Gerry Woo would have enjoyed more success after his first album (1987's 'Listen to My Heart ', which I still own). People had no idea how to market a Filipino American R&B singer, so the poor guy got dropped by his label, but it's a good thing he kept at it , because he wound up winning Debbie Allen's American Idolesque show 'Fame' in July of 2003, under the name Harlemm Lee
That is what I care.
Hotep,
Rex
-
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Mon, June 6, 2005 - 6:24 PMThe comment about you being Asian or not was because it seemed to me that you just didn't care about how Asians are disrespected or portrayed in the mainstream media. I am happy to see that you do seem to care.
I do not limit myself to any one particular culture nor do I expect anyone to. Anyone who knows me can attest to my expertise in many cultural arts (martial, healing and creative). Thats not the issue here. The issue I have is the image of Asian women in the American Mainstream. I am a teacher. I have been for a while. I have taught different levels including the youth. I know how impressionable they are. I do not mind sex-positive expression, but I do have a problem with the roles that the youth see.
The suicide rate for Asian American youth is the HIGHEST percentage of any other racial group in America. Do you wonder why?
Please remember: we are talking about Pop stars here. The music they make are aimed at our youth, but its more an issue of production and distribution. They cash in on the base, weak compulsions in our youth. I believe in freedom of expression, but not of exploitation.
There was no disrespect aimed at Kid Rock. If anything, the man has given props where props are due. THAT is why he still has game.
How many records one sells is not a measure of success. What legacy you leave is. Vanilla Ice hasn't much respect in the industry (unlike Kid Rock and the others you've cited). As Muhammad (peacebeuponhim) said, "Weath is not an issue of how much money or possessions you have, but more of ones FREEDOM FROM NEED"
Actually, Baba Oje is the spiritual GUIDE of what was Arrested Development. His voice is on their recordings and Speech has spoken on this. A spiritual guide is NOT a slave nor an accessory. Baba Oje is FAR from these psudo-Harajuku girls. He is an essential part of the group and his presence is that of a respected elder.
Speaking of respect, I know of no one more respectful to HipHop and its roots than MC Serch. Word is Bond.
Hi Hi Puffy Ami Yumi and other Japanese music groups are doing just fine without Gwen Stefani's "help". One thing Asians do have down is the concept of "Do for self."
If Asians, or any other non-white peoples, have to rely too much on white lables and promotion, then they don't deserve the fame and fortunes they are after. There are HUGE markets out there in the world. Look at Hong Kong and Bollywood film. Hollywood isn't all there is. Not even close.
I will repeat: I am sick of these demeaning portrayals of Asians, Muslims, or any other "Other". In this culture, as I have seen teaching, it really does a number on the self-esteem of the youth.
Its about respect. Respect for others, sure, but also respect for self, and I am simply a self-respecting Asian expressing my dismay over this disrespect.
Salaam,
SENSEI
-
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Tue, June 7, 2005 - 10:13 AMAfter having listened to (or rather jammed to) her lyrics, it doesn't seem to me that Gwen's intention is to disrespect the Harajuku culture but to give it praise.
As for cultural appropriation, well that's something that has been going on since there became such a thing as culture, I'd imagine. As a human race we all have something to share with each other..
As for an Asian girl posse as an accessory, I personaly wouldn't want to be in one nor would I have one but hey, to each their own. Also, it appears that these Asian women/girls are taking their power in such portrayals and there's nothing "demeaning" about that.
As for images portrayed in the mainstream (or otherwise), we all have the *personal* responsibility, as a youth or as an adult, of choosing which of them to follow.
Let's not let Anger and Frustration over how one woman chooses to express her artistic and fashion sense get the very best of us.
peace
* -
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Wed, June 8, 2005 - 4:24 PMSorry, Kaya, its just a bit of the warrior energy I have.
I am pretty sensitive about this issue, having had been a teacher for so long. It's pretty heartbreaking to come to school on a monday, seeing an empty desk of a young Asian student who off'ed herself. (-and knowing that this goes on every day here in America).
I, as an existentialist, believe that personal responsiblity (and accountablity) are what should be the norm.
Personal responsiblity for a child, however, is not really a consideration in such cases. They frequently lack the ability to separate what is real from fantasy or what is expressive from what is exploitive.
I will try to see if, indeed, these Harajuku girls are actually empowered, even though it seems to be the opinion of many people in the Asian community that it is not.
I seek peace. That's all, and as Grandmaster Leo Giron (Escrima) has said, "Peace is not the absence of conflict. It comes with the ability to deal with conflict."
I wish that student of mine (and all the other Asian youth) could find some peace.
SENSEI
- -
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Thu, June 9, 2005 - 7:13 PMI was unaware of the high suicide rate among Asian American youth, Sensei. I admit I was more focused on the homicide rate among African American youth, but you made me to recall a few things.
I remember talking with some of my Asian friends in (Performing Arts) high school about how they were under so much pressure from their families to behave according to the rigid, conservative social customs of "the old country". They weren't allowed to have friends who weren't like their parents, but they went to school with so many different kinds of cool other kids that they couldn't help but mix. Ironicly enough, now that I think of it, the other kids in their neighborhood who went to private or tech schools called them bananas (yellow outside, white inside) if they were into pop music and rotten bananas if the liked hip-hop. They were in very real fear of being disowned and cast out for bringing shame. I wonder if that kind of pressure could also factor into the suicide rate. -
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Thu, June 9, 2005 - 9:14 PMI think its definitly a contributing factor, Theodorus. I also know that Asians are very marginalized and take a huge hit against the self esteem.
My work as a teacher focused on at-risk youth, typically of marginalized communites. This included Black, Asian, Latin and Native American. I also taught many white kids in bad situations. Most of my students were gangmembers (I am a former gangmember myself) but I also taught single teenage moms, drug addicts, runaway/homeless youth, incarcerated.
One of the hardest years I had was when I had lost three students to gang related violence. Each of them were Black. There are some ugly details to these deaths that I won't go into here, but suffice to say, it was horribly tragic.
I might also add that I was a member of both the Five Percent Nation and the Nation of Islam in my younger days. I was actually one of four Filipino's in the Bay Area in it. I also have African ancestory. I happen to care a lot about what happens in the African American communities.
Peace.
SENSEI
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Thu, June 9, 2005 - 7:44 PMI just found this Tribe a few hours ago, and I joined hoping to learn how and if race fits in/doesn't fit in to BDSM and, if this applies to this Tribe, D/s.
And, I must admit, I am a bit shocked.
I would have thought, that a Tribe about BDSM would encourage freedom of expression and freedom of kink. And that a BDSM Tribe talking about race would be even more accepting of personal kink and expression. Admitedly, not everyone likes or even accepts everybody elses kink, but, to say that one's particular kink is unacceptable to everyone, or should be, except for a few things like children, incest, and non-concentual activities, is, in my view, the antithisis of what BDSM stands for. Personal freedom. (damn that was a long run-on sentance)
What I am reading here from some of the posters is heightned sensativity about race. It seems, no one can step out of their racial boundry without getting tons of shit about it. Thiese people are being so PC, and being PC and a pervert does not mix well.
If someone has an asian girl fetish. So what? Let them. It is thier kink. If Gewn S whats to use Harijuku girls to make some extra money pandering to the very common asian girl fetish, then, all the power to her. These women are not slaves, they are employees who accepted the job.
I'm gonna be watching this Tribe closely. Maybe I will learn something. But, right now, all I see is that, in a lifestyle that reeks of personal freedom, there is still the stench of racism, self hate, politcal correctness, and non-acceptance.
BTW, if there are any hot asian submissives in the LA area that like what they read in my profile, contact me. I always wanted an asian sex slave. My Thai submissive also does. -
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Thu, June 9, 2005 - 8:45 PMSorry we don't meet up to your standards.
This IS a tribe for POC's and our issues.
Hope you can let us have our discussion here and work things out for ourselves. -
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Thu, June 9, 2005 - 10:59 PMI do intend to read and hope to gain some insight...but..are you suggesting I keep quiet when I see issues I can speak to?
Is there nothing to be learned from me? After all, I am a human being, and an experienced member of the BDSM community, and in many parts of this country would not be considered white. (I am Jewish)
-
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Thu, June 9, 2005 - 10:57 PMThe "heightned sensativity about race" that you are reading, Bernie D, could be because this is a tribe whose objective is to include such an issue in the discussions.
Also I believe that "racism, self hate, politcal correctness, and non-acceptance" is not exclusive to the POC.experience/BDSM.lifestyle. It could easily be found EVERYWHERE you look..
By the way welcome, Bernie D. Enjoy watching closely as you school yourself.
MsKaya
*
-
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Fri, June 10, 2005 - 10:21 AMI'm suggesting that you be patient with us and let us communicate with one another and work things out ourselves.
Popping in with judgemental, condescending comments about us doesn't really help the conversation.
You are most welcome to observe. Peep as much as you like, but we are trying to work things out for ourselves here. Please respect that.
Just to be clear:
European decent is not POC (even Eastern Europe)
unless you are part something other than European.
Judaism is a religion, not a race.
No disrespect, just being real.
Shalom. -
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets
Fri, June 10, 2005 - 3:03 PMHi Bernie,
Since you are new, you would not have had time to have read the many discussions of race , and how it factors into the kink of People Of Color(s), in this tribe as well as other tribes to which the members here belong.
Silver Sensei and I have entertained such debates before, both sharing our points of view with an openness and honesty that indicates the passion of our conviction. For my part, I come away from these discussions enriched from the wealth of his perspective, bothe the similarities and the differences. At no time do I pay him any disrespect or assail his personal character, nor do I perceive him as doing so.
I find this kind of candor in conversation healthy, and most conducive to true familial community relations. Feel free to read through the tribe archives, and learn more about us. Welcome to the group
Hotep,
Theodorus Rex
-
-
-
Re: Gwen Stefani and her Asian Girl/Pets---I saw that on TV also...
Sun, June 26, 2005 - 4:07 PM
UNDERSTANING without judgement is a good place to start, especially is you are not a personal that is not aware of the various issues that COLOR our lives daily. HIS-Story has a way of covering up the real issues and makes us unaware of other's History.
Therefore one might say, "what is the big deal?," well that type of questions suggests that the one that is asking has not done their homework in the areas of Race and Identity in the US, plus it is a bit dismissive and does not lead to full understanding: or at least compassionate thinking about how this issue might affect others that dont look like you or have your Racial history.
ENGAGE and expand without defensivness.
HEART
San Francisco
-